What Happens When We Stop Defending Our Positions
Read the full article here: https://open.substack.com/pub/lucywishart/p/this-is-where-co-creation-actually?r=71cs29&utm_campaign=post&utm_medium=web&showWelcomeOnShare=true
Asking better questions so a new way of working can emerge in mental health teams
In mental health teams, clinicians and lived experience practitioners are increasingly working side by side. Both bring valid expertise. Both are essential.
But in practice, those perspectives are often experienced as competing. Clinicians hold risk, responsibility, and structure. Lived experience practitioners bring what doesn’t fit neatly into that frame.
So the work becomes familiar: holding positions, pushing back, explaining, translating. And not much really moves.
What I’m starting to notice is that the shift doesn’t come from resolving those differences. It comes from changing the question.
Instead of asking which perspective is right?, something else opens up: what are we missing by holding these separately?
That question changes how the room works. It stops people defending positions and allows both forms of expertise to be used at the same time.
And when that happens, something else becomes possible.
Not a compromise. Not a midpoint.
A different way of working entirely.
One that neither perspective could produce on its own.
That shift is small. But once a team experiences it, it’s very difficult to go back.
Because the work moves.
Not by choosing between perspectives, but by asking better questions so something new can emerge.



